The Constitution and the Fear of God: What the Framers Actually Believed

Nov. 19, 2026

Host: Hon. Sam Rohrer

Guest: David New

Note: This transcript is taken from a Stand in the Gap Today program aired on 11/19/26 To listen to the podcast, click HERE.

Disclaimer: While reasonable efforts have been made to provide an accurate transcription, the following is a representation of a mechanical transcription and as such, may not be a word for word transcript. Please listen to the audio version for any questions concerning the following dialogue.

Sam Rohrer:

Hello and welcome to this Thursday edition of Stand in the Gap today. And it’s also our bimonthly focus on the US Constitution and American history with recurring guest, constitutional attorney, historian, author and public speaker David New. Now, one of the most common claims made for years by some in our nation is that our American founders intended to establish a secular nation, they say largely disconnected from religion and biblical influence. Supporters of that view often point to two arguments, which we’ll address here today. You’ve heard them before, but we’ll come at them a little bit differently. The first argument is this, that the word God does not appear in the constitution. And then they come with conclusions based on that. And then second, they say that the phrase, “Separation of church and state” means religion should have little or no role in public life. Those two are the arguments that they lead with.

But before addressing those claims, perhaps we should step back and consider a more foundational question. What did the founders believe was necessary for freedom itself to survive? The Bible teaches that, “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.” That’s the verse from scripture. And when Jethro, that’s Moses’s father-in-law, if you recall, when Jethro counseled Moses regarding civil leadership, he said to select able men, men of truth, men who feared God and men who hated covetousness, establishing the fact that competence and character were inseparably linked. Then centuries later, here in my home state of Pennsylvania, William Penn observed that governments, he said, “Governments depend more upon the character of the people than the people upon government.” John Adams went even further declaring that our constitution was made only for a moral and religious people and was wholly inadequate for any other. And then in my book that I wrote a couple years ago, America’s Roadmap to Renewal, taking a lot from the writings of William Penn, I emphasized a similar principle.

God’s blessing and national stability are never primarily dependent upon governmental structure, but upon whether people and leaders acknowledge God’s authority and order their lives according to his truth. So that brings us to today’s central question. Here’s the question. Did the founders believe that constitutional self-government could survive apart from a people and leaders marked by character, accountability to God and the fear of God? Well, today we’re going to answer those questions as we examine what the historical record actually reveals about the beliefs of America’s founders and the foundations that they believe were essential for preserving liberty. And with that, David, welcome back to the program. It’s a great subject matter and we’re going to talk about that in a minute, but thanks for being back.

David New:

It’s so nice to be with you, Sam, and with everyone with us today, blessings to everyone.

Sam Rohrer:

David, let’s get into it. I want to start here. The whole program’s not going to be on this, but you’re coming out with a new book. At least put this way, you’re nearing publication of your new book. You’ve been writing on it for a long time. You and I have talked about it. You’ve entitled A History of a Christian Nation is the United States a Secular State? That’s the title I think you’re using right now. Tell us briefly about the book and why you felt it was important to write it.

David New:

One of the subjects that I cover in the book is whether the United States is a Christian nation. You don’t read too much about that among Christian writers, not directly like I do. And that’s what this book does. I list about 18 US presidents that I could find that said the United States was a Christian nation, 18 presidents and about 18 secretaries of state, a few vice presidents, several attorney generals, and I think two or three speakers of the House of Representatives. All of these people said the United States was a Christian nation and some of them included in their State of the Union address. And so we are accused of making up history and falsifying the history record whenever conservative Christians say the United States is a Christian nation. Well, that is simply not true. The evidence is compelling that the framers of our constitution and the generations, at least for six generations, were sovereignly in the camp that the United States is a Christian nation.

Sam Rohrer:

Okay. Let’s go further into this David right now because you can build that out. Let’s focus on the larger principle here before we get into the specific constitutional issues that you’re going to build out some of what you just said. And here’s the question. When you studied the founders collectively, of which you’re describing what you just said there, do you find evidence that they believed liberty and constitutional self-government depended upon the character of the people and their accountability to God? In other words, what examples most clearly demonstrate that conviction? I’ll have to go a little bit further in building out what you’re saying.

David New:

There is no question that the framers, the generation that wrote the US Constitution believed that religion was essential to a Republican form of government. A Republican form of government, which they believed in, a limited government, requires the government not to police the people, but for the people to police themselves. That means religion. And there’s no question that was the view of the early framers of our constitution and in the 13 states. In fact, in two of the state constitutions, that concept is expressly stated in the Vermont Constitution of 1777 and in the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780. The Massachusetts Constitution of 1780 is the oldest constitution still in force. The US Constitution is the oldest constitution for a national government still enforced, but the Massachusetts constitution of 1780 is the oldest constitution in the world still enforced. And here’s what the Massachusetts constitution says, as the happiness of a people and the good order and preservation of civil government essentially depend upon piety, religion and morality.

Now there you’ve got it in simple language in a state constitution that it’s still in the Massachusetts constitution, that religion is essential to good government.

Sam Rohrer:

And David, we’re out of time, but ladies and gentlemen, I know from my time in government when I spent it there and David from a constitutional perspective, that when the founders used that word religion, they were not referring to Islam, Hinduism, secularism. They were referring to the Christian religion and that was called out in many, many places. So not just religion and some spiritual thought, it was a very specific reference. Of course it makes all the difference. Our theme today is this in this title, The Constitution and the Fear of God: What the Framers Actually Believe. We’ll be back in just a moment.

Well, if you’re just joining us today, our theme, let’s put it this way, this is our bimonthly. We generally do it every other Thursday where we focus on some aspect of our US constitution, sometimes referring to state constitutions as we will today. And always, when you talk about that, you are bringing in some aspect of American history. And my guest today, we’ve done this together now for years, is constitutional attorney David New. So I want to go back at this, our theme today, as I mentioned on the other side of the break, the constitution and the fear of God, what the framers actually believed. Now, in our first segment, David and I were discussing the importance of America’s founders and the importance they placed on moral character, virtue, accountability to God, and what scripture describes as those things put together as the fear of God and what the Bible speaks about so clearly, the fear of God.

Now in many ways, those qualities were viewed at the founding of our country and for a long time thereafter, but they were viewed as essential to liberty, to preserving liberty and to maintaining self-government, which at that point of William Penn in the state of Pennsylvania where I am, he called it an experiment, a holy experiment. The whole experiment of self-government, people governing themselves under the fear of God. That’s what that means. Now, yet this brings us to one of the most common challenges raised by secularists and revisionist historians of our day and for the last many years. They argue that if the framers truly believed what David and I have described, then surely they would have mentioned God directly in the Constitution, the US Constitution. In fact, they go on to say, and they point to the absence of God’s name in the Constitution as in some cases their strongest evidence that America was intentionally designed and established as a secular nation.

To them, the argument seems simple. They say no mention of God means no intended role for God in the design of government. But is that conclusion historically accurate? Because as with most questions involving the constitution, context matters. For instance, understanding what the framers were trying to accomplish in Philadelphia in 1787, the documents they were working from and the debates they actually had may reveal a very, very different explanation. And the real question is whether the absence of God’s name in the constitution reflects the framer’s beliefs or whether it reflects something else entirely. So David, you like to talk on this. It’s important that we talk about that. So many people are convinced that the word God does not appear in the constitution, therefore the American founders intended to create a secular government. All right, here’s the question. Why is that argument so frequently made, number one, and is it even a valid conclusion?…

David New:

That they are reaching is incorrect. The reason why the word God does not appear in the United States Constitution, particularly in the preamble to the US Constitution, is because the word God does not appear in the Articles of Confederation and the preamble to the Articles of Confederation. It’s a textual reason. First, let’s clarify some things. There was no conscious decision by the framers to keep the word God out of the Constitution. It doesn’t exist. There was no vote to keep the word God out of the Constitution. There was all kinds of votes about one word versus another concerning the US Constitution, whether they wanted this word or that word in, whether they did or didn’t. There’s no such vote about this. Also, there was no debate. There was no debate concerning the issue. Should God be included in the US Constitution? They didn’t even debate that subject.

If you know anything about the framers of the Constitution and their religious background, you would know that they would never have agreed to keep the word God out of the Constitution. And our neighbors, our secular neighbors cite one brief paragraph by Luther Martin of Maryland who explained why there is no religious test in the US Constitution. And they extrapolate from that the whole concept of God itself. And he wasn’t really talking about God. He was talking about why the federal government doesn’t have a religious test. And the basic reason is the states all had their own. Some of them were similar, but some of them were not similar at all and they didn’t want to get involved. The federal government didn’t want to get involved and pick one religious test over another. They just stayed out of it completely. So why, and I cover this in one of my chapters in the book, why doesn’t the word God itself appear in the US Constitution?

It is because of the Articles of Confederation. It is a textual reason, textual. When the framers came together in Philadelphia, they were supposed to rewrite and upgrade and improve the Articles of Confederation. They were not supposed to write an entirely new constitution. Well, that creates a bit of a problem. How do you sell a brand new government completely different in many respects from the Articles of Confederation to the 13 states? What the framers decided to do was to copy the format, the text of the Articles of Confederation as much as they could and incorporate it in the US Constitution, and that would make it more sellable to the 13 states. For example, you take the clays full faith and credit in the US Constitution in article four. Well, that is a complete and total quote from the Articles of Confederation. So they copied the Articles of Confederation whenever they could.

Now, the preamble in the Articles of Confederation does not have the word God in it. In fact, what they did is they started We the States of New Hampshire and they go from North to South and they quoted the 13 states in the Articles of Confederation in their preamble. In the first drafts of the US Constitution, that’s exactly what they did. They quoted the 13 states all over again. But eventually, this will be around August 6th of 1787. But eventually in the latter part or the early part of September of 1787, they ended up saying, “Why should we list all 13 states? New states that come into the government might feel excluded if they’re not listed in the preamble. So we’re going to drop the 13 states all together.” Plus they were worried that maybe one of the 13 states might not ratify the Constitution.

There was always that danger. So they ended up with a simple, we the people. So when you look at the preamble to the Articles of Confederation, which does not refer to God, and then you look at the US Constitution, which does not refer to God in the preamble, that’s the reason they were following the text of the Articles of Confederation as much as possible.

Sam Rohrer:

All right. That’s a very good explanation. And I think of what you said there, a couple of things were very clear. It’s textual. You gave the reasons, the articles that were put together and so forth drafting. Secondly, you made it clear that there was never a vote by those who voted on the Constitution to not have God’s name inserted because no one imagined that it was necessary to do so. So that’s another thing that you were saying. You can add on to that just a little bit. I don’t have too much time left, but I want to ask you this because these who wish to state that we have a secular constitution because God’s name is not there, they make this argument that I cited earlier that says, well, if God’s name is not in the Constitution, therefore our founders did not want God’s name in the Constitution and therefore it is a God less constitution from that perspective.

That aspect of thinking and conclusion making, that’s basically a fundamentally dishonest conclusion process, is it not?

David New:

What has happened? You have to remember that all of the people that attended the US Constitutional Convention were creationists. There was not a single atheist among them. In fact, the framers of the Constitution, the state conventions that picked the delegates in several of the states, they had a religious test that they had to pass, like believing in God the Father, God the Son, and God the Holy Spirit, or believing in the Old and New Testaments. They had a religious test that they had to satisfy just to go to the convention. In other words, they were making a conscious effort to keep atheists out of the convention. That’s why not one signer of the constitution is an atheist. At the time of 1787, atheists were the social outcasts. They were the social lepers of the day. They weren’t allowed to even testify in a court of law at this time.

Sam Rohrer:

Okay, David, that’s very, very clear. Ladies and gentlemen, stay with us because when we come back, we’re going to deal with the second most common argument raised by those who say that God has no role in our country. One is that God’s name is not in the constitution. We just trust that. The other is this myth about separation of church and state. We’ll explore that next. Well, in our last segment, David and I addressed one of the most common arguments used to portray America’s founders as secularists. And we’ve talked about this in various aspects on many programs. This is a little bit different going at it in this way here today, but the claim that because God’s name does not appear in the Constitution, the framers intended to establish a secular government. That’s what the proponents of a secular government in trying to dig out and uproot any Christian biblical principles that were implemented into our founding, that’s what they say.

And we dealt with that in the last segment. And as David has explained, the historical record simply does not support that conclusion. It’s very clear. But there’s a second argument that may be even more influential today. It’s the phrase of separation of church and state. Now we’ve all heard that. You probably all have your own way of maybe defining it because it is so confused and it is so deceptive. Now for many Americans, these four words, separation of church and state have become a shorthand way of arguing that religion and specifically the Christian religion as our founders really connected religion and Christianity together, they say it should remain private, that biblical principles should have little influence on public policy and that references to God in government are somehow inconsistent with America’s founding ideals. Yet what’s interesting is that the phrase itself never appears in the constitution either.

Now, instead of not appearing there, it comes from a letter, a reference written by Thomas Jefferson years after the constitution was ratified. And the question is whether modern Americans understand that phrase the same way that Jefferson and the founders understood it, or as I would submit, maybe they don’t even care about what Jefferson wrote or why he wrote what he did, but honesty would prevail that we do ask that question. So if as we’ve discussed, the founders believed that constitutional liberty depended upon virtue, moral character, accountability to God and the fear of God, then it seems unlikely that they intended to remove all religious, particularly Christian religious influence from public life. So the issue before us, I think right now is not whether church and state are distinct institutions. We know they are. The issue is whether the founders intended to separate government and those in government from an established church, religion, established church denomination, or whether they intended to separate government from God himself.

And that’s a key question. David, the phrase separation of church and state, one of the most quoted, I’m going to say least understood phrase in American history. Where did the phrase actually originate and what was Thomas Jefferson actually responding to? What was he trying to communicate when he used that phrase, separation of church and state?

David New:

Our secular neighbors have never understood the separation of church and state. They do not understand what it meant. They do not understand what it means, and it’s not likely that they ever will. The separation of church and state is simply talking about institutionalizing the separation of the two bodies. The church governs itself independent of the government. The government governs itself independent of influence from the church in the sense that, for example, when the United States declared war on the Japanese of World War II, the president did not have to go to any religious authority to get permission to do that. The institutions are separated. These people on our secular side are claiming that it means that God has no role in the government and that is completely false. The person that wrote about the separation of church and state, as you indicated correctly, is Thomas Jefferson.

Thomas Jefferson was a creationist. If you read his Dan Berry letter of 1802, where he says that the American people, which declare that their legislature should make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof fuss building a wall of separation between church and state.

Read the rest of the letter. The very last sentence, “I reciprocate your kind prayers,” Jefferson said to the Danbury Baptist Association, “A religious association. I reciprocate your kind prayers for the protection and blessing of the common father and creator of man and tender you for yourselves and your religious association assurances of my high respect and esteem.” When the secularists talk about the separation of church and state, they are reading it through the eyes of Charles Darwin and the theory of evolution. That will change your interpretation of what the separation of church and state means. When Jefferson was talking about the separation of church and state, he was thinking of it in terms as a creationist, that he acknowledged the existence of God, the common father and creator of man, which means all features of human existence, family law, business law, government law, constitution, sports, entertainment, everything is under the sovereignty of God.

So he’s interpreting the separation of church and state as a creationist concept, not evolutionary. Charles Darwin is the origin for secularism in the United States. It is not the framers. Remember, the framers did not like atheism. And one of the ways we can note to a moral certainty that they did not establish a secular government for the United States is that the concept of atheism and secularism are so close that to the framers, they would be indistinguishable. To have one is to have the other. For them to believe in an atheist government would be horrifying for them to believe in a secular state amounts to atheism. So why doesn’t the constitution have a lot to say about religion? It has precious little, very little to say about religion. Is it because they were a bunch of card carrying members of the ACLU? No. The reason is because the constitution, the national government has no authority over religion.

The entire subject was left to the states. And for that reason, the US Constitution has precious little to say about religion. But because of Darwin, our secular neighbors interpret that to mean that the framers were not interested in God and government and all of this sort of thing. So they are misinterpreting, they are misreading the tea leaves when they say it’s secular. No way is that possible. They never even used the word secular. Before the United States became a secular state in the 50s and 60s and so forth, the federal government was not described as a secular state. It was described as a civil government, which is very, very different. So Jefferson was trying to keep sectarian religion out of government. He was not trying to keep religion all together out of government.

Sam Rohrer:

Okay. And very, very clearly by what you’re saying, David, it would have been absurd for anybody to suggest that God and one’s personal belief in biblical truth, God as creator, these things we’re talking about, for those not to be together and to be reflected in civil government would have been totally absurd and you’re making that point. But I want you to clarify one thing here. At the beginning of our country, when our nation was put together, there was a model that existed in England that actually did connect government and church and they didn’t want what was in England. Speak to that just briefly.

David New:

Yes, this is true. England, and even today it’s still this way. Charles is the head of the church in England. He’s not just the king of England, but he’s also the head of the British Anglican church. So when they in England, church and state are united and America The revolution was, in England, it goes from God to the king to the people. In America, in the Declaration of Independence, it goes from God, the people, to the government. That was the American Revolution in a nutshell, going from God, king to the government, and going from God to the people, to the government. And that’s the American revolution. We separate church and state in this country. When they use the term separation of church and state, when you read how they use it, they don’t use it as a secular concept because they didn’t even know this concept of what a secular state was.

There was no debate about it. They never even discussed the subject. It never comes up. And so these people that are fabricating that this country is a secular state, it is junk history.

Sam Rohrer:

All right. And ladies and gentlemen, I hope that this is helpful to you. A lot of great information here, and it really is simple, but we have to know the truth in order to separate it from the errors that we hear. When we come back, we’re going to conclude with what the framers actually believed about God, liberty, and national blessing, and kind of put some of these principles together about which we’ve been focusing here today. Well, as we go into our final segment here today, again, the theme, if you’re perhaps just joining us late today, the focus has been the Constitution and the Fear of God, what the framers actually believe. And we started with the connection of the fear of God, competency and character, and the fear of God required for self-government. We visited and discussed two of the leading arguments that those who do not want to recognize God and to cut out or eviscerate any reference to our founders’ beliefs and dependence upon God and recognition of fear of God, that first reference that God’s name does not appear in the Constitution, therefore they come to a faulty conclusion that our framers didn’t like God.

Second is separation of church and state. And we touched about that in the last segment. So we’re moving here now to the end and hoping to summarize a few of these things because the historical record overwhelmingly demonstrates that the founders linked liberty, morality, religion, Christian religion, and God’s blessings. And then there’s a question that remains, and we’ll deal with this briefly in this segment. Can constitutional liberty survive when the fear of God and moral character disappear from a people and their leaders? And our founders spoke to that issue too. So we’ve looked at these things here today that I just went through, yet when we step back and then we look at the broader historical record, a very different picture begins to emerge than what the secularists would like us to believe. The question is no longer whether the framers mentioned God in a particular document or used a particular phrase.

The larger question becomes, what did they actually believe about God? We’ve touched a lot about it on that already. Religion, Christian religion, morality, virtue, and the kind of character required for liberty to survive. And as we’ve discussed today, constitutional government assumes self-government. And I could repeat that a dozen times. It’s important to know constitutional government assumes self-government, but self-government assumes a people capable of governing themselves, all of which our founders talked about in depth. And the framers repeatedly spoke and that’s why they referred to virtue, morality, religion, duty, providence and accountability. In other words, they believed that the success of America’s constitutional framework ultimately depended less upon the structure of government and more upon the character of the people and those in government. And that brings us to our governing question here for today. Did the founders believe that constitutional self-government could survive apart from a people and leaders marked by character, accountability to God and the fear of God?

All right, David, let’s go in your forthcoming book, referred to it, A History of a Christian Nation is the United States a secular state. And I don’t believe this book is available at the moment, but it’s about, it’s coming there. So I want to ask you about that, but you’ve assembled extensive documentation from signers of the Constitution and other founders regarding God, Christianity, virtue, morality, role of religion, all these things we’ve talked about. But looking at the historical record as a whole, David, what does that evidence reveal about what the framers actually believed concerning the relationship, that’s the key, relationship between liberty, moral character, accountability to God and the preservation of constitutional government? Because when they laid these things down, David, this was still a hope. It was by and large a dream. It hadn’t yet come about. So speak to that relationship and how they viewed it.

David New:

Yes. In my book, the appendix one is entitled Were the Framers Indifferent Towards Religion. And I go through and I put a paragraph in there talking, I summarize them and then I give the details of each framer what they had to say. Ladies and gentlemen, it’s important to understand that at the time of 1787 and subsequent years, whether you put the word God in the constitution or not didn’t have the significance that it has today. What made it significant was Charles Darwin. For example, you take the Northwest territory, which created five states out of that area, Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Michigan, parts of Minnesota, many of their first constitutions did not have the word God in the preamble either. Some of those words about God, Almighty God, were not added until 40 or 50 years later. And the reason is at that time, since everybody was a creationist, they didn’t see and consider by not adding the word God, you become godless.

That comes later with Darwin. You take the 1776 Constitution of New Hampshire, the word God appears nowhere in it. And yet New Hampshire had an official government religion, the congregational church up until it’s either 1818 or 1819. And the word God appears nowhere, but yet it has an official religion. Okay. So there were about 12 to 15 people who had a vote on whether to ratify the Constitution and those 12 or 15 people said, “I’m not voting for this because the word God doesn’t appear. I’m not voting because I don’t see anything about Jesus or something.” All right. David, they’ve got to be secondary because 12 to 15 people said so. They weren’t going to vote for the Constitution for that reason. Wrong again. The total number of votes from the 13 states that voted whether to vote for or against ratification of the Constitution and the vote was 65% yay and 35% nay.

The total number of people was 1,648. 1,648. Some students will have a larger number, slightly larger or slightly smaller, but that’s my number. These 12 to 15 people don’t even make one half of 1% of the total vote. Let me go and read to you what I said in my book. This is one of the opening paragraphs in that appendix one. And here’s what it says. Two signers of the United States said that the United States was a Christian nation. People don’t know that a signer of the Constitution said that. Two of them did. Seven said America was a free Protestant English settlement. George Washington was one of those seven. One signer objected to the Treaty of Tripoli because it said the government of the United States was not in any sense founded on the Christian religion. This signer said, “What else is it founded on?” Two signers of the US Constitution said the law of God was supreme over man’s law.

One said the Holy Spirit should guide America. Six said America should confess her sins to God. Three signers wanted Christianity to spread throughout the whole world. One of them said the knowledge of God should cover the earth as the waters cover the sea, back in 2:14. Four signers were presidents, vice presidents or managers of Bible societies. Another said the Bible should be a law book for the US government. One signer wrote a book to prove that the Bible was scientifically accurate. Three wanted Christianity taught in the schools. One signer wrote a law that effectively put prayer in the Bible and the public schools. Another signer made that same law a federal law and put religion in the schools nationwide.

Sam Rohrer:

And David, you could go on and on and ladies and gentlemen, we’re just out of time right now, but you get the idea. You have to be fundamentally dishonest, not to understand that God’s hand prevailed in the foundation and laying down of what we have and so long have enjoyed in this country. Thanks for being with us today. We’ll see you back tomorrow.

 

Verified by MonsterInsights